• Login

Sun, May 19 2013

Gabriel Hershman

All who stammer are not stupid

Fri, Dec 10 2010 13:54 CET 7312 Views 6 Comments
All who stammer are not stupid

Photo: Wikipedia

I once worked in an office near a benign but rather simple soul who was also an ardent royalist. On the wall above her desk was a photograph of the Queen Mother with her husband King George VI. 

The Queen Mother was a national institution, just like fish and chips. Even republicans had to grudgingly concede a certain respect for this robust matriarch who undertook a hectic schedule well into her 90s. It just wasn't cricket to say anything else. So the woman in question, along with many others, worshipped the Queen Mum.

The same employee, however, had little good to say about King George. When someone passed her desk and commented on the photo, she'd say "She's a marvellous lady, ain't' she? Shame about 'im, though (King George), he was a weak man, you know, he had the most dreadful stu'er". She said this repeatedly, I mean several times a week. 

The casual equation of stammering with weakness was/is a common perception. Or people thought that if you stammered you either weren't very bright or you were simply nervous.

Life was also much tougher for stammerers 20 to 30 years ago, pre-internet, pre-mobile and pre-email. In those days if you stammered badly you often felt utterly alone. Communication advances mean that those with speech problems now feel more connected. But even in the 1990s I remember feeling frustrated at the ignorance of the general public and employers towards the affliction.

Organisations like the British Stammering Association, whose interview with Colin Firth we reproduce with their kind permission, faced an uphill battle to get funding and attention when set against more visible disabilities and illnesses. And that's in no way to diminish the sterling efforts of its current Chief Executive, Norbert Lieckfieldt or his equally gifted predecessor Peter Cartwright. 

The King's Speech could be a defining moment for people who stammer. Films have depicted stammerers before – most notably One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest (a fine portrayal by Brad Dourif) but too often stammerers were comic figures. Ronnie Barker was a stupendously gifted comic actor but  – to be honest – his portrayal of Arkwright in Open All Hours was not his finest hour. He acted as if the character he portrayed was merely stumbling over his speech, as if stammering was just a kind of bumbling dysfluency. Those people familiar with stammering will tell you that it's a condition characterised by struggle and, sometimes, by avoidance.

In 1988 A Fish Called Wanda hit the cinemas. This divided the stammering community. Some found it deeply offensive because the Michael Palin character was a figure of fun. Others thought that stammerers' very sensitivity about their problem was a vicious circle and that any publicity was essentially good publicity. I was in the latter camp; in fact, it became one of my favourite films. Still, what was needed was a serious depiction of stammering in a film.

Now The King's Speech has appeared. The Oscar buzz is turning into a roar and, although I never count chickens, it's gathering momentum. I haven't seen the film but I trust the opinion of the current Chief Executive of the British Stammering Association, Norbert Lieckfieldt, when he says that Colin Firth has done an excellent job in depicting the silent, strangulated blocks that characterised King George's stammer.

So, dear former colleague (NOT) I refuse to believe that King George was a weak man just because he stammered, just as I disregard Hitler's recorded description of King George as "a simpleton". King George confonted his fears head on and succeeded in inspiring the nation during the darkest days of World War 2.

I'm not saying that all stammerers are clever, neither am I saying that there aren't any stammerers who are nervous – although often it's a case of what came first – the nervousness (about speaking) or the stammer. But we should resist assumptions about people until we get to know them.

Congratulations again to everyone involved in making The King's Speech, particularly Colin Firth, director Tom Hooper and screenwriter David Seidler.

  • Print
  • Send via email
  • Translate to
  • Share:

Comments

Anonymous Epaminondas Fri, Feb 11 2011 19:03 CET

Well done, Gabriel - a fine and perceptive article ! I hope you are right about the Oscar - the film deserves it.

Anonymous1Fri, Feb 11 2011 08:24 CET

This comment has been removed by the moderator because it contained off-topic content

AnonymousLoisFri, Feb 11 2011 08:23 CET

This comment has been removed by the moderator because it contained off-topic content

Anonymous To Jim Fri, Jan 14 2011 12:16 CET

I guess we should try to focus on ourselves as whole people and see our stammer as just part and parcel of a wider picture. But I know what you mean. I've seen that look countless times myself.

Anonymous jim Thu, Jan 13 2011 02:09 CET

i notice that a lot of stutterers have a common look in their eyes, something developed over years of personal struggle, frustration, and often torment. i have this look as well.

Anonymous birdy Sat, Dec 11 2010 09:09 CET

thank God for some normal things..


To post comments, please, Login or Register.


Please read the The Sofia Echo forum comments policy.

The King's Speech wins Best Picture Oscar

Film also earns best actor, director, screenplay honours

The King's Speech rules the Baftas: Gallery

Best film, outstanding British film, best actor for Colin Firth, best supporting actress for Helena Bonham Carter and best supporter actor for Geoffrey Rush - but Social Network wins best director

The King's Speech nominated for 14 Baftas

The British Academy of Film and Television Arts released its list of film award nominees on January 18 2011, with The King's Speech receiving nominations that include best film, outstanding British film, and best original screenplay.

Social Network takes top Golden Globes Prize

Firth, Portman earn top acting honours.

More in this category

Move Russia’s capital from Moscow to Siberia?

Sergei Shoigu, the newly appointed governor of the Moscow Region, recently proposed that Russia move its capital to Siberia. The idea was immediately squelched.

Kremlin TV channel to US: No reset

RT seems to wish we were back in the USSR.

Blog: Time to end the UK's wacky welfare system

Some clergy suggested the UK government's proposal to cap annual state benefits at 26 000 pounds is 'unchristian'. Really?

Blog: On Worral Thompson and a shoplifter's motive

There is no such thing as a 'typical' shoplifter and there are many motives for people to steal.

Blog: Ed Miliband should never have challenged his brother

In essence Ed only has himself to blame; he set his stall to the Left of his brother and now seems lost as to what to do.