Sofia Echo


A Portuguese lesson for Bulgaria?

Author: Gabriel Hershman Date: Sun, Dec 12 2010 6 Comments, 9397 Views
Share: share on Twitter share on Facebook Share on Google+ Share on LinkedIn
Print Send via email

Portuguese prime minister José Sócrates has apparently assured the world that his country does not need a bailout. Alarm bells must be ringing everywhere.

The recent history of Portuguese politics is not particularly reassuring. Perhaps, however, Bulgaria could heed some important lessons from Portugal's shortcomings.

Where shall we start? Well, I trust by now you've all heard of José Manuel Barroso, the current head of the European Commission? Barroso became prime minister in 2002, having inherited a dreadful mess from his predecessor, António Guterres, who became the UN high commissioner for refugees. (I've often wondered if Portuguese prime  ministers are rewarded for failure).

Perhaps Barroso's most significant "achievement" was "doing the catering" (his own words) on the Azores for the pre-Iraq war summit, attended by former US president George Bush and former British prime minister Tony Blair in early 2003.

Back in Portugal, Barroso was deeply unpopular. He suddenly resigned in 2004 to take up his new position in Brussels. He was replaced by Pedro Santana Lopes, former mayor of Lisbon. No election took place. Lopes' short spell in charge was marked by administrative blunders and personal gaffes. The election of 2005 came before the official end of his term and was called at the behest of the then president Jorges Sampaio. (In Portugal the president has the prerogative of dissolving parliament and calling elections  – a power known as "the bomb".)

The 2005 election was a policy-free zone. Lopes tried to steer TV debates towards the issues. Sócrates merely stated repeatedly that Portugal needed "a good government" but gave no details.

Far-left parties were omnipresent during the campaign. The head of the Portuguese communist party, Jerónimo de Sousa, debated on live TV with Sócrates and Lopes. In what other European country, I wondered, would the communist leader be given equal air time as the mainstream candidates? The head of the Bloco de Esquerda, (the left bloc) Francisco Louçã, also appeared on every news bulletin. Louçã was a sensitive-looking intellectual who would have been at home on a student campus circa 1968.

Watching this strangely outdated contest made me feel that Portugal was out of step with the rest of Europe. Sócrates, of course, won by a landslide, confirming the truth of the old saying that "oppositions don't win elections, governments lose them". Santana Lopes, after all, had become a risible figure.

Sócrates promised change but little came. In Portugal it's difficult for the socialists to implement change of any kind, beholden as they are to special interests. Charges of "betrayal" resound from every corner, particularly, of course, the communists. When Álvaro Cunhal, a former secretary general of the communist party, died shortly after the 2005 election, the country fell into national mourning. This was a die-hard communist who worshipped the Kremlin. Yet he was feted like a hero. 'Nough said. 

Things should have been a lot better for Portugal. When Lisbon joined the EEC (as it was then called) in 1986, it was a time of great excitement. Portugal received 42 billion euro in structural funds and 6.3 billion euro in cohesion funds over the next 20 years. A massive construction boom ensued. Its good side was a transformation in the country's dilapidated motorways. Its bad side was that too many ugly building started to mar the coastal skyline. Yet nobody complained.

Successive Portuguese governments believed that tourism would continue to be the country's most lucrative industry. Unfortunately, countries like Florida, Turkey and Thailand pulled in the punters by offering better service and cheaper prices. Funding of education and training also fell back. In 2007 it was estimated that investment in research and development was only 40 per cent of the EU average. Companies also relocated abroad where labour costs were lower.

Sadly, the construction industry has now gone belly up. Portuguese resorts are now littered with half-finished projects, abandoned hotels and villa developments. And the problems endemic in Portugal  – overmanning and restrictive working practices  – have continued unabated.

Sócrates narrowly won re-election in 2009. Now, however, the chickens have come home to roost, as well as every other cliche about the Portuguese economy, namely that it has a bloated public sector, the private sector is uncompetitive and the economy too dependent on tourism. Meanwhile, EU funds have, of course, long since dried up and Socrates' socialists have been forced to pass an austerity budget.

Taking heed, Bulgaria?

  • EU leaders agree on permanent bailout mechanism
    • Anonymous neutral
      #6 13, 04, Thu, Dec 16 2010

      robert in moldavia dream on! and look after your own interests first

    • Anonymous
      vasco da gama Rating:
      #5 09, 04, Tue, Dec 14 2010

      let's have a drink and change the subject.

    • Anonymous
      Sceptic Rating:
      #4 12, 59, Mon, Dec 13 2010

      Re Pedro:
      A Bulgarian friend went to Faro University in Portugal and reported that the standard of skills and training was low. Illiteracy levels are higher than in Eastern Europe. The country seems to shut down for at least two hours every afternoon. Tourist regions have dealt with the crisis very badly - by pushing up prices rather than trying to offer competitive rates. Lisbon is a beautiful city but it has failed to make the most of itself. Basically, it punches below its weight. Drug addiction is rife, shops are poorly presented and new trends and fashions [...]

      Read the full comment despised. The whole area around Lisbon's Praça do Comércio should be revamped and modernised so that it becomes a more attractive outdoor cafe area. It has a lot to offer but obviously the mayors or city planner whoever they are have not done a great job. It's full of abandoned council buildings. Old graffiti is everywhere in Lisbon, indeed everywhere. What was the point of the over-construction that has ruined placed on the Algarve like Armacao de Pera?

    • Anonymous
      Pedro Rating:
      #3 11, 56, Mon, Dec 13 2010

      According to PISA - Portugal was the country that most improved its education levels in the past decade. Portugal has made it significantly easier to open a business. The Portuguese speaking world is booming - think Angola / Brazil. If you compare the Portuguese deficit and total debt to the US or UK we compare favorably. Tourism is overstated - we are betting on technology - Embraer invested in a new plane manufacturing facility. We produce cheap laptops for children around the world. We are a world leader in renewable energy. Our banking sector is international - covering Poland to [...]

      Read the full comment Angola. We have recently opened a new medical research facility - one the most sophisticated in the world. The author should investigate before simply copying the trash from the Anglo Saxon media.

    • Anonymous neutral
      #2 04, 51, Mon, Dec 13 2010

      come on, robert in france that is a little dramatic. The eu will help all of us who need assistance.

    • Anonymous neutral
      #1 19, 00, Sun, Dec 12 2010

      I have been saying this for years every country who thinks that eu aid can help them in the long run are sadly wrong. Bg must find its own solidity and never depend on eu funding to create basic infrastructure, it must neither fall in to the "tourist" trap or sell amenieties to foreign
      business who have no time for local or national issues and will export any profit to cayman etc.....BEWARE

    To post comments, please, Login or Register.
    Please read the The Sofia Echo forum comments policy.